Welcome to day two of the "all-porn week" (also known as a desperate attempt to draw traffic in the face of a summer slowdown) here at Bombs, Boobs and Burgers. Today, some interesting news out of Japan: porn is reportedly overloading the country's mobile phone networks.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/bea2c/bea2c2bc8e8fbe821d09cb36246b0cb45c92d9ef" alt=""
According to Bloomberg, Japan's mobile carriers - who are light years ahead of their North American peers in technology - are starting to complain about how much their customers are using the networks. Some of that use, they suspect, is coming from people who are using their phones to download movies, particularly those of the adult persuasion. According to a spokesman for KDDI, one of Japan's biggest mobile companies, "We can't see customers' data but can surmise the biggest portion of it is probably movies. We can't deny the possibility those movies include adult content."
Some of the analysts quoted in the Bloomberg story, however, are saying the issue is more serious than the carriers are letting on. "Pornography will eventually open a debate about how carriers should modify their business model as data traffic swells," said one telecommunications analyst in Tokyo. "It may prompt even tighter access restrictions."
Now hold on a second. Those sorts of statements tend to set warning bells off for me. It's ironic that Bloomberg, a pro-business newswire if there is one, would run such a story on the very day that Canadian telecommunications regulators convened a public hearing into net neutrality, kicking off the debate on how much control internet providers should have over the services they provide to customers. According to reports, the issue of whether net neutrality rules should apply to mobile phones came up at the CRTC hearings. On day one, a couple of the companies that make the network technologies for Canadian carriers, namely Sandvine and Juniper Networks, argued that yes of course, mobile companies should have the right to manage traffic as they see fit. That means limiting it or slowing it if they think it's necessary.
It sounds like some of the analysts quoted in the Bloomberg story are drinking the same Kool-Aid. Speaking from experience, many telecom analysts are shills who put forward the agendas of the companies they cover. In exchange, they get business from the telecom companies. It sure looks like that's what happened in the Bloomberg story, which is one lazy piece of reporting and editing. Never mind the factual errors, like the suggestion that Japan may be the first country to impose mobile download limits (hello, anybody used a cellphone in Canada, lately?) or the preposterous claim that Japan produces about 17,000 adult titles a year, an output that would vault it ahead of L.A.'s San Fernando valley - the porn capital of the world - and its paltry 14,000 or so films a year. The story, quite simply, is misleading and, I think, the product of an agenda. What bugs me most about it is that these analysts are stealthily trying to use porn, that old boogeyman, as an excuse for future net neutrality violations.
Perhaps the thing that angers me most about the telecom industry is how it sells internet access. First, the providers charge a lot of money and suck in only those people who absolutely must have it. Then, they lower prices and capture the mass market. Once the customers are there and find they can't live without it, the carriers start complaining that their customers are actually using the service, and they try to restrict it in various ways. It's completely disingenuous. If you're going to sell a service, you'd better be prepared to have your customers use it. Otherwise, don't bother.
If there's one quote that can be believed in the Bloomberg story, it's that from a Japanese porn executive who said that while mobile porn is growing, the market is "still relatively untouched." As I've posted here before, porn producers
are excited about the potential of mobile porn and the
market is growing, but it'll be a long time before it overloads anyone's network.
By the way, if you're wondering why there's a picture of Godzilla in this post, it's because no story on Japan is complete without one.